Potbelly Sandwich Works Shakes, Cookies & Drinks Prices (2026)
The Potbelly Sandwich Works shakes, cookies & drinks menu runs from $1.99 to $6.49 in 2026, averaging $3.85 across 8 priced items. Every item is listed below with its current price.
Saving Money on Potbelly Sandwich Works Shakes, Cookies & Drinks
- Order Skinny instead of Original to save $1.50 — the bread and toppings are identical, only the meat portion changes.
- Pick Your Pair at $11.49 beats a full sandwich plus a side ordered separately by about two dollars.
- Potbelly Perks gives a free cookie on signup and a free Original sandwich after your first few qualifying visits.
- Order in the app for pickup — Potbelly runs app-exclusive discounts that never appear on delivery platforms.
Potbelly Sandwich Works Shakes, Cookies & Drinks Prices — FAQ
How much is the cheapest item on the Potbelly Sandwich Works shakes, cookies & drinks menu?
Chips is the cheapest shakes, cookies & drinks item at Potbelly Sandwich Works, at about $1.99 in 2026. The next cheapest options are Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie ($2.29) and Sugar Cookie ($2.29).
What is the average Potbelly Sandwich Works shakes, cookies & drinks price in 2026?
Across the 8 priced shakes, cookies & drinks items we track, the average is $3.85 and the midpoint is $2.99. Prices run from $1.99 for Chips up to $6.49 for Malt.
Is Potbelly Sandwich Works shakes, cookies & drinks expensive compared with other chains?
2 of the 6 comparable chains we track are cheaper on shakes, cookies & drinks. Subway averages $2.48 against $3.85 at Potbelly Sandwich Works — a gap of about 36%.
Do Potbelly Sandwich Works shakes, cookies & drinks prices vary by location?
Yes. Potbelly Sandwich Works franchisees set their own prices, so the same item can differ by a dollar or more between neighbouring towns, and airport, stadium and highway locations run higher still. The figures here are the prices that appear most often across U.S. markets.