Jersey Mike's Subs vs Jimmy John's Prices: Which Is Cheaper? (2026)

The short answer

Jimmy John's is the cheaper of the two. Of the 5 directly comparable items we could match across both menus, Jimmy John's is cheaper on 3 of them, by an average of $1.84 per item.

Typical menu price: Jersey Mike's Subs $10.40 ยท Jimmy John's $9.99

Deals Worth Knowing at Both

Jersey Mike's Subs

  • Mike's Mini Bundle pairs any Mini cold sub with regular chips for $7.99. A Mini Original Italian and chips would be $9.79 bought separately.
  • Mike's Hot Italian was $8.95 for a Regular and $16.95 for a Giant at all three restaurants, the cheapest hot sub on the menu.
  • A wrap or a bowl costs the same as a Regular sub, so skipping the bread does not save money.

Jimmy John's

  • Slims โ€” plain meat, bread and cheese โ€” cost about $2 less than the equivalent Original and are the cheapest sandwiches on the menu.
  • Freaky Fast Rewards gives a free sandwich roughly every eighth visit plus a birthday reward.
  • Ordering pickup instead of delivery saves the roughly $3 delivery fee and the small delivery markup on menu prices.
About these prices: menu prices are set by individual franchise owners and change without notice. The figures on this page are researched estimates for 2026 and are provided for reference only. Confirm the current price with the restaurant before ordering. Menu Price Book is not affiliated with this chain.

Jersey Mike's Subs vs Jimmy John's โ€” FAQ

Is Jersey Mike's Subs cheaper than Jimmy John's in 2026?

Jimmy John's is cheaper on most matched items โ€” 3 of 5. Across the whole menu Jimmy John's is the lower-priced of the two, at $9.99 for a typical item against $10.40 at Jersey Mike's Subs.

What is the price difference between Jersey Mike's Subs and Jimmy John's?

On matched items the average difference is $1.84, or about 17% overall. Jersey Mike's Subs averages $12.78 across 73 priced items; Jimmy John's averages $10.57 across 27.

Which has the cheaper entry price, Jersey Mike's Subs or Jimmy John's?

Jersey Mike's Subs starts at $4.35 (Cookies (three pack)) and Jimmy John's at $1.99 (Jumbo Kosher Dill Pickle).

Are these prices the same at every location?

No. Both chains let franchise owners set prices, so figures move by a dollar or more between markets and run highest at airport, stadium and highway locations. Treat these as the typical U.S. price, not a quote.

Full Menus